Post by pandawinner1972 on Oct 2, 2011 13:29:00 GMT -5
Grading the 2009 Draft
1. Matthew Stafford - A great QB when he is on the field but injuries have plagued him, now he is coming into his own this year. A-
2. Jason Smith - Not a good pick at all, never lived up to his status as a great Olineman. C-
3. Tyson Jackson - This is the second year the Chiefs choose a below average Dlineman. C+
4. Aaron Curry - Ehh... Never lived up to what he expected but still has Poetintial needs to work hard to not be a bust. B--
5. Mark Sanchez - He is the weak spot for the Jets, of they picked Josh Freeman they could have won the SB. B
6. Andre Smith - Contract issues and overweight plus being an underachiever equals a bust. C
7. Darius Heyward Bey - Terrible player, no hands and only speed but hey this is the Raiders. D+
8. Eugene Moreno - Last year the Jags picked Harvey and this is the second year they picked a bad interior lineman. D-
9. B.J. Raji - A very good pick by the Packers and has set them at DT one of the few good lineman this year. A-
10. Micheal Crabtree - Is an underachiever and not worthy of this pick but he still has poetintial and was better than Heywad. B-
11. Aaron Maybin - Cheesh the Bills... Never thought he was gonna be good and now he isn't good. D-
12. Knowshone Moreno - A solid pick but RB's are a dime a dozen should have been picked in the second round. B-
13. Brian Orakopo - Very, very good player and is a star in this draft possibly top 10 LB at his position. A+
14. Malcom Jenkins - Was always iffy about this guy but he has been an average player nothing more nothing less. C+
15. Brian Cushing - Was coming on strong until he got caught with PED's but can still be a good player. B
16. Larry English - Never like other players is living up to his hype another average player. C+
17. Josh Freeman - Amazing pick that other teams missed on. Great pick by the Bucs eith a franchise QB. A+
18. Robert Ayers - Similar to Derrick Harvey is that he is a bad Dlineman that will never live up to the hype. D+
19. Jeremy Maclin - A great WR to help compliment to Desean Jackson and I think he could be a solid Number 1. A-
20. Brandon Pettigrew - A great solid pick by the Lions which solidified their TE for years to come and help Stafford! A-
21. Alex Mack - A great center which just may make them the best Oline in football with Joe Thomas. A+
22. Percy Harvin - A solid WR but not the best here maybe could have gotten another player. B-
23. Micheal Oher - A good solid player but since he plays RT it diminishes his value. B
24. Peria Jerry - Soild player but not worthy of this pick but there was no other Olineman avaible better than him. B
25. Vontea Davis - A great pick by the Dolphins which helped their CB's and can be a top 5 CB. A-
26. Clay Matthews - Best player in this draft, and possibly the best LB at his position. A++
27. Donald Brown - Colts need to figure out you need a good Oline and not a good RB, nota good pick but a solid player. C+
28. Eric Wood - A good solid center that was worthy of this pick but not good enough because you need a LT, and RT. B-
29. Hakeem Nicks - Now the Number 1 WR for the Giants which means this was a very good pick. A
30. Kenny Brit - A very good WR and is the number 1 WR for the Titans improves them plenty. B+
31. Beanie Wells - Not a good pick because there were better players aviable and nor even the starting RB. C+
32. Evander Hood - A nice solid player but will never get his chance because the Steelers D is so good. C+
Overall : 10 A's / 10 B's / 8 C's / 4 D's / 0 F's / Overall : A-
1. Matthew Stafford - A great QB when he is on the field but injuries have plagued him, now he is coming into his own this year. A-
2. Jason Smith - Not a good pick at all, never lived up to his status as a great Olineman. C-
3. Tyson Jackson - This is the second year the Chiefs choose a below average Dlineman. C+
4. Aaron Curry - Ehh... Never lived up to what he expected but still has Poetintial needs to work hard to not be a bust. B--
5. Mark Sanchez - He is the weak spot for the Jets, of they picked Josh Freeman they could have won the SB. B
6. Andre Smith - Contract issues and overweight plus being an underachiever equals a bust. C
7. Darius Heyward Bey - Terrible player, no hands and only speed but hey this is the Raiders. D+
8. Eugene Moreno - Last year the Jags picked Harvey and this is the second year they picked a bad interior lineman. D-
9. B.J. Raji - A very good pick by the Packers and has set them at DT one of the few good lineman this year. A-
10. Micheal Crabtree - Is an underachiever and not worthy of this pick but he still has poetintial and was better than Heywad. B-
11. Aaron Maybin - Cheesh the Bills... Never thought he was gonna be good and now he isn't good. D-
12. Knowshone Moreno - A solid pick but RB's are a dime a dozen should have been picked in the second round. B-
13. Brian Orakopo - Very, very good player and is a star in this draft possibly top 10 LB at his position. A+
14. Malcom Jenkins - Was always iffy about this guy but he has been an average player nothing more nothing less. C+
15. Brian Cushing - Was coming on strong until he got caught with PED's but can still be a good player. B
16. Larry English - Never like other players is living up to his hype another average player. C+
17. Josh Freeman - Amazing pick that other teams missed on. Great pick by the Bucs eith a franchise QB. A+
18. Robert Ayers - Similar to Derrick Harvey is that he is a bad Dlineman that will never live up to the hype. D+
19. Jeremy Maclin - A great WR to help compliment to Desean Jackson and I think he could be a solid Number 1. A-
20. Brandon Pettigrew - A great solid pick by the Lions which solidified their TE for years to come and help Stafford! A-
21. Alex Mack - A great center which just may make them the best Oline in football with Joe Thomas. A+
22. Percy Harvin - A solid WR but not the best here maybe could have gotten another player. B-
23. Micheal Oher - A good solid player but since he plays RT it diminishes his value. B
24. Peria Jerry - Soild player but not worthy of this pick but there was no other Olineman avaible better than him. B
25. Vontea Davis - A great pick by the Dolphins which helped their CB's and can be a top 5 CB. A-
26. Clay Matthews - Best player in this draft, and possibly the best LB at his position. A++
27. Donald Brown - Colts need to figure out you need a good Oline and not a good RB, nota good pick but a solid player. C+
28. Eric Wood - A good solid center that was worthy of this pick but not good enough because you need a LT, and RT. B-
29. Hakeem Nicks - Now the Number 1 WR for the Giants which means this was a very good pick. A
30. Kenny Brit - A very good WR and is the number 1 WR for the Titans improves them plenty. B+
31. Beanie Wells - Not a good pick because there were better players aviable and nor even the starting RB. C+
32. Evander Hood - A nice solid player but will never get his chance because the Steelers D is so good. C+
Overall : 10 A's / 10 B's / 8 C's / 4 D's / 0 F's / Overall : A-